Energy: Shifting From Bullish To Neutral

Inventory Draws Need to Continue for This Oil Rally to Have Legs

Back in May as oil prices corrected from the high $80s to mid $70s, the energy sector provided a terrific buying opportunity for both long term energy bulls and oil traders alike. Sentiment and positioning had been washed out on fears OPEC+ would increase production and unwind their voluntary cuts, all at a time where demand was set to rise and inventories draw as we entered peak demand season in the northern hemisphere.

Oil prices have since rallied back to the mid-$80s as hedge funds and CTAs have re-entered the market en masse following the overreaction to OPEC+’s planned production cut unwinds. But this rally has thus far played out on the anticipation of impending inventory draws through July and August as opposed to actual inventory draws, leaving crude oil prices in a somewhat vulnerable position.

Now, we did have a very bullish inventory draw of ~12m barrels last week. But, prior to this, inventory changes have been firmly in the bearish camp for both total crude oil and petroleum products as well as crude oil itself for much of the past few months.

Crude oil inventories generally draw at this time of year. Ditto gasoline stocks. Up until last week overall inventories had been building at higher-than-normal rates, particularly for gasoline.

One culprit is likely to be crack spreads, which as we can see below, although they have stabilised since bottoming out in early June, have only modestly moved higher over the past month.

Even though crack spreads and refinery margins have spent the past month at their lowest levels since early 2023, this hasn’t stopped refinery throughput climbing to well above seasonal averages following weather induced refinery outages and an extended maintenance season earlier this year.

As a result, gasoline stocks in particular have been replenished at a higher-than-normal rate over the past quarter along with overall petroleum and crude inventories. While demand has been relatively strong over the past month, it hasn’t been strong enough to offset increased refined product supplies.

As a result, for oil prices to remain at current levels and to avoid an unwinding of net-long oil futures positioning, we likely need to see a combination of:

• Cracks spreads continuing to rally in-line with oil prices, which should help incentivise refiners to sustain crude throughout and draw down crude inventories;
• Refined product demand to continue to rise during what is generally the favourable time of the year consumption wise; and,
• Refined product inventories to draw in addition to crude oil inventory draws.

If we don’t see overall inventory draws and cracks spreads roll over, oil prices are likely to sell-off back to the mid-$70s level, with energy stocks to follow suit.

The Outlook for Demand

In terms of the outlook for demand over the next six to 12 months, though it is incredibly difficult to predict, I continue to lean toward the bullish side of the equation. Both oil prices and a large part of demand does move in-line with the global business cycle, as we can see below.

And, as regular readers can attest to, the leading indicators of the US business cycle continue to suggest economic growth and the manufacturing cycle is set to expand over the coming six to 12 months.

The same can be said for the global business cycle, as we can see below.

So, while it is definitely possible we see economic disappoint in the short-term, an upswing in the global manufacturing sector will help the demand picture for oil and refined products from a cyclical perspective.

Positioning and Other Considerations

Turning our attention toward investor positioning, as I have mentioned, managed money positioning in WTI (made up of hedge funds and CTAs) has spiked to levels generally indicative of short-term tops in prices. On the flip side, we have seen big positioning unwinds in gasoline and diesel futures as prices for both have collapsed in recent weeks.

This leaves convexity likely skewed to the downside for oil and to the upside for the refined products. As a result, should the oil market fundamentals disappoint, oil prices are almost certain to sell-off.

Supporting the bearish thesis for oil prices in the short-term is seasonality. July through August are generally weaker months for price action.

We have also seen WTI time spreads spike to levels that generally align with short-term tops in prices.

Though it is true a backwardated term structure is a bullish sign for oil, when the spread between front month and dated futures spike to such a significant degree, this tends to suggest the rally is running out of steam. The below study from SentimenTrader illustrates this well.

A Quick Word on OPEC+ and US Oil Production

Taking a look at the bigger picture now, it is interesting to note US production has effectively been flat for much of the past six to nine months. Production saw a big ramp-up last year, which I believe was at least partly due to private producers maximising production in order to entice takeovers. In the months since, production growth has stalled. While this recent plateau doesn’t tell us much in isolation, given I reside in the camp of US tight oil production likely nearing its peak at some point this year or next, this is an interesting sign post.

From the OPEC+ side of things, we did see the cartel layout their plans to bring back part of their voluntary cuts. Beginning in October this year, 2.2 mm b/d in production cuts will start to be unwound progressively over the following 12 months, subject to market conditions. Given where current OPEC+ production lies and how these production increases will occur slowly over a 12-month period, I would be surprised if this were to have a material impact on oil prices, barring a recession.

It is also important to remember OPEC+ production cuts have hardly translated into a reduction in global supply. Outside of August last year and June this year, OPEC+ exports have been at or near average levels seen prior to production cuts. What’s more, the drop in June exports can largely be attributed to Saudi Arabia keeping barrels domestically to feeds its power plants during hot weather as energy demand is at seasonal highs, in addition to Hajj, the annual Islamic pilgrimage to the Muslim holy sites of Mecca and Medina. So, perhaps the OPEC+ story isn’t quite the story it’s cut out to be. Time will tell.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways

• Oil prices have rallied nicely following the overdone sell-off in May.
• Hedge funds and CTAs have been buying oil and fuelling this rally on the expectation of future inventory draws through the summer months.
• This leaves positioning stretched to the upside, so for oil prices to continue to rally we must see consistent inventory draws in July through August, otherwise oil prices will sell-off. Crack spreads will be a key driver of this dynamic.
• Even if fundamentals are bullish, there remains a $85-90 ceiling on oil prices in 2024, given the election and the US production story is unlikely to be a major factor for 2024. Short-term growth risks may also play a role here.
• The medium-term outlook beyond 2024 remains relatively robust, so long as we don’t have a major recession. The outlook for demand remains positive as the manufacturing cycle picks up globally, while OPEC+ production increases are likely to be a non-factor given the slow pace to which they are being unwound. The growth is US production over the next 12-24 months is likely the key determinant of whether we do eventually see a big rally in oil prices and energy stocks.