Advertisement
Advertisement

China’s Economy is in Trouble: The Warning Signs Are Clear

By:
James Hyerczyk
Published: Sep 9, 2024, 08:29 GMT+00:00

Key Points:

  • China's CPI grew by just 0.6% in August, falling short of expectations, signaling weak consumer demand and deflation risks.
  • Producer prices have fallen for 23 consecutive months, with PPI declining by 1.8% year-over-year in August, indicating severe overcapacity issues.
  • Former Bank of Japan Governor warns China may face deflation similar to Japan's "lost decades" unless swift action is taken.
  • Despite stimulus, economists see China’s current policies as overly focused on supply, failing to revive domestic consumption.
China CPI

China’s Sluggish Inflation Data Sparks Deflation Concerns

China’s economic challenges are becoming harder to ignore, with the latest data on consumer and producer prices raising serious concerns. Despite efforts to stimulate demand, the country is grappling with stubborn deflationary pressures, declining producer prices, and tepid consumer demand. Here are the key warning signs that point to a deeper problem in the world’s second-largest economy.

Weak CPI Growth Signals Low Demand

China CPI YoY

In August, China’s consumer price index (CPI) rose by just 0.6%, falling short of the 0.71% economists had expected. While this was a slight improvement from July’s 0.5% increase, it did little to ease fears of deflation. For over a year, China’s CPI has hovered near zero, far below Beijing’s annual target of 3%. This signals that consumer demand remains weak, despite government measures to boost spending.

Core inflation, which excludes food and energy prices, was also lackluster, rising only 0.3% year-on-year. This suggests that underlying inflationary pressures remain absent, further highlighting weak domestic consumption. Even as food prices surged, especially pork and vegetables, broader demand in non-food categories showed minimal growth.

PPI Decline Highlights Overcapacity

China PPI YoY

While consumer prices are barely rising, factory-gate prices continue to fall at an alarming rate. China’s producer price index (PPI) declined by 1.8% year-over-year in August, marking its 23rd consecutive month of deflation. This persistent drop highlights a broader issue of overcapacity in industries like fuel and metals, where production continues to outstrip demand.

Persistent declines in the PPI indicate that businesses are struggling to maintain pricing power, which could lead to lower corporate earnings, reduced investment, and further pressure on the labor market. This deflationary cycle is reminiscent of Japan’s “lost decades,” where deflation and stagnation paralyzed the economy for years.

Deflation Fears Are Growing

Economists have raised concerns that China is at risk of entering a prolonged deflationary period, similar to Japan’s experience in the late 20th century. According to the South China Morning Post, former Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko Kuroda warned that China must act swiftly to avoid this fate. He noted that deflation, once entrenched, can be extremely difficult to reverse, as seen in Japan, where wage stagnation and falling prices created a vicious cycle of weak demand and slow growth.

Former People’s Bank of China Governor Yi Gang echoed these concerns, also reported by South China Morning Post. He urged Beijing to focus on combating deflationary pressures with active fiscal and monetary policies. Yi emphasized the need to stimulate domestic demand, stabilize the real estate market, and address local government debt.

Stimulus May Be Too Little, Too Late

While Beijing has implemented a series of stimulus measures, including interest rate cuts and fiscal spending, the effects have been limited so far. The government’s shift toward consumption-led policies has yet to yield significant results, and many economists believe that current policies remain too focused on the supply side, failing to adequately address the demand shortfall.

Looking ahead, China’s economic prospects appear dim unless stronger action is taken to address these underlying issues. Without decisive intervention, the country risks sliding further into a deflationary trap that could stifle growth for years to come.

Market Outlook: Bearish

Given the weak inflation data, ongoing PPI deflation, and mounting concerns over deflationary pressures, the outlook for China’s economy remains bearish. Traders should brace for continued volatility, as the current stimulus may not be enough to lift demand or reverse the deflationary spiral gripping the country.

About the Author

James is a Florida-based technical analyst, market researcher, educator and trader with 35+ years of experience. He is an expert in the area of patterns, price and time analysis as it applies to futures, Forex, and stocks.

Advertisement