Will Starbucks Share Profit from the New CEO?

Niccol has taken over for Laxman Narasimhan, who has resigned from his position since the statement made by Starbucks on August 13.

Niccol’s leadership at Chipotle was marked by exceptional financial performance, in addition to his focus on employee well-being, strategic advertising, innovation, and menu development. Under his guidance, the company experienced explosive growth, with revenue doubling, profits increasing sevenfold, and the stock price skyrocketing nearly 800%.

His proven ability to drive substantial value creation is evident in his previous role at Taco Bell, where he successfully spearheaded a turnaround by introducing innovative menu items, including breakfast.

As Niccol is well-known for his successful leadership at Chipotle, it is anticipated that he will bring effective leadership to Starbucks. But will Niccol’s appointment be able to reignite investor interest in Starbucks stock?

Starbucks Shares Have Been Stagnating Over the Last Few Years

After gains of over 26.40% in 2020 and 8.90% in 2021, the stock took a downturn in 2022, losing approximately 15% of its value amidst market volatility. The downward trend continued into 2023, with a loss of around 4.60%. The stock price remained nearly flat for the year as of August 16th, but it had plummeted nearly 25% between January and May to its lowest point since June 2022.

Starbucks stock has experienced a resurgence in August, with a significant price jump and a bullish gap on August 13 of almost 18%. This surge has propelled the stock price above key technical indicators. Could this be suggestive of strong upward momentum?

While there’s potential for further upside, given the rapid ascent, a price correction towards the 87.593 or 84.30 support levels could also be on the horizon. Alternatively, if the bullish trend persists, resistance levels at 98.432 and 103.917 could come into play.

Starbucks: A New Brew of Challenges for Niccol

Niccol will become the fourth CEO of Starbucks in 2 years. He steps into the role of Starbucks CEO at a challenging time where the coffee giant is grappling with a perfect storm of issues that threaten its market dominance.

Declining Sales: Starbucks has reported a significant decline in performance during its fiscal third quarter. Net income and sales dipped compared to the previous year, with same-store sales plummeting by 3%. This downturn was primarily driven by a sharp 5% decrease in transactions, indicating a decline in customer visits.

The U.S. market experienced a particularly steep decline in store traffic, falling by 6%. The situation was even more dire in China, Starbucks’ second-largest market, where same-store sales tumbled 14% due to a decrease in both average spending and customer visits.

Higher Customer Dissatisfaction: Customer complaints about inflated prices, order delays, long waits, and a lacklustre food menu underscore the company’s struggle to maintain its value proposition. This, coupled with broader economic pressures on consumers, has eroded customer loyalty.

Rising Chinese Competition: Starbucks’ challenges extend far beyond its domestic market. China, once a beacon of growth, has transformed into a battleground for the coffee giant.

The Chinese economy is experiencing a slowdown, leading to increased consumer caution. Despite significant investments and store expansion, Starbucks has witnessed a dramatic decline in market share, losing ground to formidable domestic competitors such as Luckin Coffee, Hey Tea, Nayuki, and even Tim Hortons according to the Financial Times.

The crux of the issue lies in Starbucks’ premium positioning. While this strategy has been successful in high-tier cities, it has hindered the company’s ability to tap into the vast, lower-tier market, which has been instrumental in the growth of competitors like Luckin. To effectively compete in this space, Starbucks would need to make substantial investments in store expansion and potentially reposition its brand, a costly and risky endeavour.

The confluence of economic headwinds, intense competition, and the need for strategic recalibration poses a significant challenge for Starbucks in China. Successfully navigating this complex landscape will be crucial for the company’s overall global performance, as China is now the second most important market for the American coffee company.

Shifting Business Model Challenges: The coffee giant’s heavy reliance on drive-thru and mobile ordering, while boosting sales, has created operational complexities.

Mobile orders account for approximately one-third of Starbucks’ sales, according to CNBC. However, these orders often involve complex customizations, which can slow down service and contribute to barista burnout. This, combined with the company’s previously acknowledged struggles to meet morning demand, has led to increased wait times and customer dissatisfaction. To address these issues and improve the overall customer experience, Starbucks will need to invest in technological advancements to streamline the mobile ordering process.

Concurrently, Starbucks is locked in a fierce battle for market share with specialised drive-thru competitors and the growing convenience of home coffee brewing. Striking a balance between serving in-store customers and meeting the demands of the digital age will be a formidable challenge.

Labour Unrest and Operational Pressures: The surge in unionisation efforts among Starbucks employees highlights a growing discontent with working conditions and benefits. Addressing these issues while maintaining operational efficiency will be a delicate balancing act for Niccol.

Disclaimer

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. Between 66% and 83% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

ActivTrades Corp is authorised and regulated by The Securities Commission of the Bahamas. ActivTrades Corp is an international business company registered in the Commonwealth of the Bahamas, registration number 199667 B.

The information provided does not constitute investment research. The material has not been prepared in accordance with the legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is to be considered to be a marketing communication.

All information has been prepared by ActivTrades (“AT”). The information does not contain a record of AT’s prices, or an offer of or solicitation for a transaction in any financial instrument. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information.

Any material provided does not have regard to the specific investment objective and financial situation of any person who may receive it. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. AT provides an execution-only service. Consequently, any person acting on the information provided does so at their own risk.