Stocks remained largely unchanged on Wednesday as investors prepared for the first Federal Reserve interest rate cut in four years. Uncertainty over the size of the cut, however, kept gains muted. The Fed is expected to announce its decision at 18:00 GMT, with a reduction of at least 25 basis points widely anticipated. Still, traders are split on whether the central bank will opt for a more aggressive 50-basis-point cut.
At 14:24 GMT, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is trading 41511.07, down 95.11 or -0.23%. The S&P 500 Index is at 4628.50, down 6.08 or -0.11% and the Nasdaq is trading 17613.50, down 14.56 or -0.08%.
According to the CME Group’s FedWatch tool, there is a 61% chance of a half-point cut, with 35% odds favoring a quarter-point reduction. The heightened uncertainty is unusual, as the Federal Reserve typically signals its moves well in advance. Until recently, most traders were expecting a smaller cut, but in the last week, expectations for a more significant reduction have gained momentum.
Jim Reid, head of global economics at Deutsche Bank, noted that such uncertainty so close to a decision is rare. “You’d have to go back over 15 years to find such an uncertain situation this close to the decision. A lot of money will be made and lost today,” Reid commented.
Despite the uncertainty, the S&P 500 remains strong, trading near record highs after an 18% gain this year. Historically, markets tend to perform well following a rate cut, with Canaccord Genuity data showing that the S&P 500 averages a 16% gain in the 12 months after the first cut in a new cycle. Tuesday saw a mixed session as the S&P edged up by 0.03%, while the Dow and Nasdaq posted modest losses and gains, respectively.
On Wednesday, sector performance across the board was mixed as markets awaited the Federal Reserve’s rate cut decision. Defensive sectors, like consumer staples and real estate, saw modest gains, while energy and materials struggled amid uncertainties in the broader market.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average components also experienced mixed results on Wednesday, with tech and financial stocks under pressure, while consumer and industrial companies posted gains.
Oil prices have dipped nearly 1% ahead of the rate decision, as the potential for a small cut has already been factored into the market. Matt Smith, lead oil analyst at Kpler, noted, “In theory, a rate cut is supportive for oil prices, but we’ve seen prices rally in recent days, likely pricing this in already.”
If the Fed opts for a larger 50-basis-point cut, oil prices could see a modest rise, particularly due to the effect on the U.S. dollar. Andy Lipow, president of Lipow Oil Associates, explained, “A 50 basis point cut is slightly supportive of the oil market since it translates into a weaker dollar and stronger prices for dollar-denominated commodities.” However, the oil market remains focused on broader supply and demand issues, including softening demand in China and OPEC+ plans to increase production.
The near-term outlook for equities remains uncertain, with downside risks heightened heading into the Fed meeting. Analysts at BTIG have expressed concern about the potential for a “false breakout” following the Fed’s announcement, cautioning that the market’s risk-reward ratio is skewed to the downside. With consumer staples facing notable risk, traders should remain cautious, especially in sectors more sensitive to rate cuts.
Overall, while a smaller rate cut is already priced in, a larger-than-expected move could offer short-term upside for stocks and oil prices, particularly if it spurs a weakening of the dollar. However, broader concerns about economic growth and global demand suggest traders should prepare for volatility.
James is a Florida-based technical analyst, market researcher, educator and trader with 35+ years of experience. He is an expert in the area of patterns, price and time analysis as it applies to futures, Forex, and stocks.